
I made an apple crisp yesterday. What, you ask, does that have to do with science? Hear me out.
So I was sitting at the computer last night after dinner, enjoying a bowl of that wonderful dessert, and feeling a little guilty that I could balance the bowl on my stomach as I typed. Fortune smiled on me, though, as I came across an article from Scientific Reports titled "Metabolic changes following relief of upper airway obstruction promote rebound weight gain in mice". After reading the article, I felt better about my atrocious eating habits. Laypersons sometimes say to me, "Sure, Tom, you may understand all this sciencey stuff, but how does it relate to me, an uneducated ignoramus? Why did this article give you the resolve to have another bowl of apple crisp before bed?"
Well, ill-informed layperson, because the article told me that the fact that all of my pants are suddenly in the "relaxed fit" category is not really my fault. I was recently diagnosed with sleep apnea and started on CPAP, which is not just a diabolical machine that pumps air up your nose, but also turns out to be a great scapegoat for weight gain.
In the study, some folks at Ben-Gurion University took a bunch of mice and placed little silicone bands around their windpipes to partially block their breathing. I'm guessing these were not mouse volunteers. The researchers figured that, with silicone bands around their windpipes, the mice would be sort of like me and all the other sleep apnea sufferers whose airways partially close at night. They admitted that this wasn't really, really like sleep apnea, but what the heck, they had the mice and the silicone bands, and nobody could think of a better use for these two items. If you wonder if a lot of science projects get decided like this, the answer is yes.
Once the mice were semi-choking, the researchers watched them for a couple of weeks and noticed they all lost about 7% of their weight. Then the researchers removed the silicone bands from half the mice and noticed that those mice packed on weight until they were 15% fatter than mice who were lucky enough to avoid the study altogether. What does this information tell us? It tells me that if they put a band around my neck for two weeks, I probably wouldn't be able to wolf down two bowls of apple crisp in one night for fear of choking to death.
The researchers no doubt felt that such a simple answer hardly justified all their work with the mice, and therefore concluded something entirely different. They decided that when someone has sleep apnea, the fact that they stop breathing multiple times a night makes their sympathetic nervous system (the old "fight or flight" system) rev up, and it doesn't get un-revved just because you quit semi-dying from stopping your breathing several times an hour. No, that sympathetic nervous system keeps telling you to go ahead and eat more apple crisp. They even gave the mice a drug called a beta-3 blocker, which in theory should set everything back to normal. But even the drug didn't fully stop the mice from eating whatever they eat and gaining weight.
There's another article from the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine from 2021 that blames CPAP weight gain on fluid retention. That works for me too. By the way, the journal's website says they put out 18,500 copies a month and charge $837 a year for an institutional subscription. Maybe you get a free coffee mug when you sign up.
And that's why I'm thinking of finishing off the last serving of apple crisp in the refrigerator. It's not my fault my sympathetic nervous system is flogging my better judgment into submission. Or it's fluid retention, or something else entirely beyond my control. It's all the fault of the machine sitting on the nightstand by my bed. Whatever the researchers conclude, I think we can agree that the science has shown unequivocally that I'll have to keep buying bigger pants.